Comment on : “Bus Uncle”
1. How many viewers are estimated to have watched the youtube video?
According to Youtube there are more than 100 million people have watched the video.
2. How would you rate the video?
I would give a lower mark for the video.
--. Is it of high quality in technical terms?
Is it interesting aesthetically eg camera angles, use of light, the narrative, and so on? I think the video is made of a poor quality in term of technique, since I cannot find any valuable or aesthetic value on the video, the whole editing technique was quiet common or not special.the camera angles was just like from a voyage angle, there are no lighting or narrative skills.
-- Does it raise interesting socio-cultural issues?
It does raise some socio-cultural issues, such as it releases the pressure among the society; it shows that there is a great pressure in the society. It also tells that when we are facing the conflict, we can deal it with a more peaceful way, such as negotiation rather than using violence. And the video shows that people tend to speak louder voice in order to strengthen their position, as we can see from the video, people tend to shake their hands as a mean of settle down or a deal.
3. Do you think it deserved the attention that it received from the internet community?
I think it doesn't deserve the attention that it received from the internet community. Since the video was just about a common arguments among people, it was not special and not worth for paying attention on it. People notice that because it can more or less arouse some noise, just like other video.
4.Do video-sharing sites such as Youtube enhance or worsen creative culture?
I think video-sharing sites such as YouTube does enhance creative culture. Since YouTube or other video-sharing sites provide a platform for the people to communicate, to share ideas and to exchange opinion. Those functions helps to create variety information and collect different ideas, which will make a great contribution for the development of a greater diversity of the society and form a creative culture in a long term. However just mentioned by Marek in "Creativity meets Circulation: internet, amateurs and the Process of evolution”,"It almost seems like there are no external boundaries for the creativity of the community, except for legal issues and digital rights management efforts." The creativity should be put under the protest of the law, if not people's work will be reproduce time by time, such as the original video clip called "Leave Britney Alone!" was reproduced by many other version, such as the digital version of "Leave Britney Alone!" I think the reproduce of a piece of idea does not help to promote the creativity. So I think there should be law to guide the YouTube.